Member's Mark Custom Two-Tier Cake
Item # 984294398
Current price is USD$57.98
Prices may vary in club and online
Bakery, in club pickup
Next-day pickup if ordered by 2 PM. Cakes can be ordered up to 30 days in advance and picked up in the Bakery area within the club.
Columbus, Hilliard Sam's Club
Return or replace anytime.
SNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery only
Get a $30 statement credit¹ when you open an account 9/1-9/30/26 + learn how to earn 10% back on fuel for a limited time‡ See details
Highlights
- Made fresh in Club
- Two-tier cake serves ~58 people
- Design may vary; customize your order online
- Great for birthdays, themed parties and celebrations
- Choose a custom message for your cake
We also recommend
The Rustik Oven Sourdough Bread, 16 oz. $4.28 $0.27/oz
$428
current price $4.28$0.27/oz
The Rustik Oven Sourdough Bread, 16 oz.
4.3056 out of 5 stars
Sponsored
Hero image 0 of Member's Mark Custom Two-Tier Cake, 0 of 1
Members also considered
Member's Mark Breakfast Platter, Five Flavor Assortment, 40 ct. $20.93 $0.52/ea
$2093current price $20.93$0.52/eaMember's Mark Breakfast Platter, Five Flavor Assortment, 40 ct.
21854.1451 out of 5 Stars. 2185 reviews4.1451 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryAssorted Cookie Tray, 84 ct. $19.93 $0.24/ea
$1993current price $19.93$0.24/eaAssorted Cookie Tray, 84 ct.
81554.6938 out of 5 Stars. 8155 reviews4.6938 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Chocolate Chunk Cookies, 18 ct. $7.48 $0.42/ea
$748current price $7.48$0.42/eaMember's Mark Chocolate Chunk Cookies, 18 ct.
164854.7643 out of 5 Stars. 16485 reviews4.7643 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Holiday Cookie Tray, 60 ct. $19.93 $0.33/ea
$1993current price $19.93$0.33/eaMember's Mark Holiday Cookie Tray, 60 ct.
18684.333 out of 5 Stars. 1868 reviews4.333 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Cookies Variety Pack, 18 ct. $7.48 $0.42/ea
$748current price $7.48$0.42/eaMember's Mark Cookies Variety Pack, 18 ct.
64294.5343 out of 5 Stars. 6429 reviews4.5343 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliverySam's Vanilla Whipped Icing, Frozen, Bucket, 13 lbs. $33.66 $2.59/lb
$3366current price $33.66$2.59/lbSam's Vanilla Whipped Icing, Frozen, Bucket, 13 lbs.
2134.7465 out of 5 Stars. 213 reviews4.7465 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for PickupPickupMember's Mark 4" Assorted Mini Pies, 6 ct. $10.74 $1.79/ea
$1074current price $10.74$1.79/eaMember's Mark 4" Assorted Mini Pies, 6 ct.
3504.4 out of 5 Stars. 350 reviews4.4 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Fall Assorted Donut Tray, 20 ct. $17.64 $0.88/ea
$1764current price $17.64$0.88/eaMember's Mark Fall Assorted Donut Tray, 20 ct.
SNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for PickupPickupMember's Mark Mini Candy Cookies, 36 ct. $7.78 $0.22/ea
$778current price $7.78$0.22/eaMember's Mark Mini Candy Cookies, 36 ct.
36084.3268 out of 5 Stars. 3608 reviews4.3268 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Gourmet Brownie Tray, 24 ct. $20.93 $0.87/ea
$2093current price $20.93$0.87/eaMember's Mark Gourmet Brownie Tray, 24 ct.
12004.3 out of 5 Stars. 1200 reviews4.3 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Iced Cinnamon Rolls, 8 ct. $9.62 $1.20/ea
$962current price $9.62$1.20/eaMember's Mark Iced Cinnamon Rolls, 8 ct.
8083.6015 out of 5 Stars. 808 reviews3.6015 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Cinnamon Rolls, Frozen, Case, 96 ct. $80.72 $0.84/ea
$8072current price $80.72$0.84/eaMember's Mark Cinnamon Rolls, Frozen, Case, 96 ct.
153.4667 out of 5 Stars. 15 reviews3.4667 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Danish Variety Pack, 4 ct. $5.98 $1.50/ea
$598current price $5.98$1.50/eaMember's Mark Danish Variety Pack, 4 ct.
5653.715 out of 5 Stars. 565 reviews3.715 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Gourmet Brownie Tray, Frozen, Case, 96 ct. $71.32 $0.74/ea
$7132current price $71.32$0.74/eaMember's Mark Gourmet Brownie Tray, Frozen, Case, 96 ct.
64.8333 out of 5 Stars. 6 reviews4.8333 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Cream Cheese Danish, 4 ct. $5.98 $1.50/ea
$598current price $5.98$1.50/eaMember's Mark Cream Cheese Danish, 4 ct.
3483.8793 out of 5 Stars. 348 reviews3.8793 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDelivery
About this item
Product details
Step into the captivating world of celebrations with our delightful Fully Customizable Member's Mark Custom Two-Tier Cake— making it the ultimate centerpiece for your celebrations. Crafted to serve up to 58 guests, this cake ensures that every slice is filled with both joy and delectable taste.
Theme-tastic Customization: Make It Yours!
Beyond its captivating appearance, this cake boasts a symphony of flavors that will leave your taste buds dancing. The moist layers of cake, combined with sumptuous fillings, create a harmonious blend. And guess what? You're in control! Dive into a world of endless possibilities with personalized options for the cake base, decorations, icing and even a special message. Choose from a range of flavors that cater to various palates, ensuring everyone finds their favorite.
Crafted with Passion
Our bakers pour their expertise and passion into every cake they create. Using only the finest ingredients and upholding the highest standards of craftsmanship, we ensure that your Custom Two-Tier Cake not only looks spectacular but also tastes exceptional.
info:
If the item details above aren't accurate or complete, we want to know about it.
Specifications
Cakes & cupcake orders can be picked up the Bakery area within the club.
Member ratings & reviews
Filtered and sorted results would be available on the new 'Customer ratings & reviews' page.
Sort by |
Showing 1-3 of 3 reviews
Jul 8, 2026
Reviewer name: anonymous
5 out of 5 stars
Wedding cake!
Had this cake as my wedding cake. Couldn't have asked for a better tasting and cheaper option. So yummy and so gorgeous. The price, unbeatable
Helpful?59VJ94JRF1XZ18360554946
Mar 6, 2026
Reviewer name: JENNIFER
3 out of 5 stars
Good base cake
The cake was not l level on the top or bottom layers. The crest had not been removed off the bottom teir so the top layer did not sit flush and was raised a good amount all the way around. There was a large area exposed between the 2 layers of cake of cake disc and cardboard. The bottom layer was not placed on the cake board in the center. Finally, the cake itself was not iced evenly with areas of cake exposed through the icing. The cake tasted great though and we got lots of compliments on the taste. I intended om decorating this cake from the beginning because I read other reviews. Do not buy this without the intent to decorate it and finish it yourself. For the taste and size, I still think it was a good deal and would buy again. I will post pics after I decorated it below. (the top layer is a clear cake tier with blue water and swimming fish and was added seperately).
Helpful?59VJ94JRF1XZ18360554946
Jun 8, 2026
Reviewer name: Lorraine
1 out of 5 stars
Cake was not decorated as I requested. No borders %26 no welcome baby
Helpful?59VJ94JRF1XZ18360554946
Popular products in this category
Member's Mark 12" Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie, 72 oz. $10.98 $0.15/oz
$1098current price $10.98$0.15/ozMember's Mark 12" Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie, 72 oz.
50494.5605 out of 5 Stars. 5049 reviews4.5605 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark All Butter Cocktail Croissants, 20 ct. $5.96 $0.30/ea
$596current price $5.96$0.30/eaMember's Mark All Butter Cocktail Croissants, 20 ct.
3134.5208 out of 5 Stars. 313 reviews4.5208 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark French Baguette, 2 ct. $4.46 $2.23/ea
$446current price $4.46$2.23/eaMember's Mark French Baguette, 2 ct.
30294.3991 out of 5 Stars. 3029 reviews4.3991 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryLa Banderita 9” Homestyle Soft Taco Flour Tortillas, 24 ct. $4.18 $0.08/oz
$418current price $4.18$0.08/ozLa Banderita 9” Homestyle Soft Taco Flour Tortillas, 24 ct.
21204.6991 out of 5 Stars. 2120 reviews4.6991 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Holiday Muffin Variety Pack, 6 ct. $6.82 $1.14/ea
$682current price $6.82$1.14/eaMember's Mark Holiday Muffin Variety Pack, 6 ct.
8283.8 out of 5 Stars. 828 reviews3.8 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Sliced Brioche Slider Buns, 24 ct. $5.98 Was $6.98 $0.25/ea
Instant Savings
Now$598current price Now $5.98, Was $6.98$6.98$0.25/ea$1 offEnds Oct 12Member's Mark Sliced Brioche Slider Buns, 24 ct.
32204.6981 out of 5 Stars. 3220 reviews4.6981 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Jumbo Hoagie Rolls, White Bread, 6 ct. $6.98 $1.16/ea
$698current price $6.98$1.16/eaMember's Mark Jumbo Hoagie Rolls, White Bread, 6 ct.
18174.5685 out of 5 Stars. 1817 reviews4.5685 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryPillsbury Southern Style Biscuits 2 oz., 24 pk. $6.98 $0.15/oz
$698current price $6.98$0.15/ozPillsbury Southern Style Biscuits 2 oz., 24 pk.
17524.6079 out of 5 Stars. 1752 reviews4.6079 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for ShippingShippingMember's Mark French Bread, 2 ct. $2.98 $1.49/ea
$298current price $2.98$1.49/eaMember's Mark French Bread, 2 ct.
19174.5138 out of 5 Stars. 1917 reviews4.5138 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryAunt Millie's Hot Dog Buns, 16 ct. $3.18 $0.13/oz
$318current price $3.18$0.13/ozAunt Millie's Hot Dog Buns, 16 ct.
9294.564 out of 5 Stars. 929 reviews4.564 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Central American-Style Bolillo Rolls, 18 ct. $7.36 $0.41/ea
$736current price $7.36$0.41/eaMember's Mark Central American-Style Bolillo Rolls, 18 ct.
13094.3254 out of 5 Stars. 1309 reviews4.3254 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Fall Cutout Cookies, 15 ct. $10.92 $0.73/ea
$1092current price $10.92$0.73/eaMember's Mark Fall Cutout Cookies, 15 ct.
6884.4 out of 5 Stars. 688 reviews4.4 out of 5 starsAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Blueberry Sliced Bagels, 6 ct. $3.82 $0.64/ea
$382current price $3.82$0.64/eaMember's Mark Blueberry Sliced Bagels, 6 ct.
4924.3 out of 5 Stars. 492 reviews4.3 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryAunt Millie's Hamburger Buns 16 ct. $3.48
$348current price $3.48Aunt Millie's Hamburger Buns 16 ct.
7794.638 out of 5 Stars. 779 reviews4.638 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryHostess Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake, 1.44 oz., 32 pk. $9.98 $0.31/ea
$998current price $9.98$0.31/eaHostess Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake, 1.44 oz., 32 pk.
17284.6858 out of 5 Stars. 1728 reviews4.6858 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDelivery