Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs.

Item # 423255
Current price is $9.22
$4.61/lb
Prices may vary in club and online
How do you want your item?

Curbside Pickup

Free with your membership on eligible items
Columbus, Hilliard Sam's Club
Aisle J4
Not eligible for return.
SNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery only
Sam's credit card
Get a $30 statement credit when you open an account and use it to make $30 in eligible Sam's Club purchases within 30 days¹.

Highlights

  • Super for snacking!
  • Try it paired with roasted nuts and ice-cold ale
  • Excellent for cooking
  • Naturally lactose-free and gluten-free

Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs. $8.97 $4.49/lb

Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs.
current price $8.97
$4.49/lb

Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs.

4.7737 out of 5 Stars. 1838 reviews
Sponsored
Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs.
Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs.
Hero image 0 of Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs., 0 of 11

About this item

Product details

Creamy white in color and almost crumbly in texture, this Extra Sharp Cheddar packs a punch, followed by a citrusy tang. Magnificent melted into cheese sauce, or atop a juicy burger.

The Cabot Name Says It All

New England Cooperative Cabot Creamery, founded in 1919, is a nationally known name for award-winning cheese. 500 families own the creamery and supply the milk from their farms. Cabot NY Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Brick has an "East Coast cheddar bite", and with 7 grams of protein in every one-inch cube, it makes for excellent low-carbohydrate snacking. Pair it with fruit and a glass of wine or roasted nuts and chilled beer.

Ways to Use It

Grate this New York extra sharp yellow cheese over pasta to add pep, melt it on rustic bread for a sophisticated grilled cheese, sprinkle over grilled vegetables for a healthy entree, blend it into a simple quiche for that wow factor–or cut into cubes and eat it plain. Any way you slice it, it's good!

Easy to Melt

New York Extra Sharp is the perfect texture for melting. The preferred method for melting is to shred the cheese so that is uniformly shaped, then allow it to rise to room temperature. Make a roux of flour and fat (to thicken the sauce) in a non-stick skillet and then, keeping the heat on low, add the cheese. Stir frequently and don't walk away. Once the cheese is smooth, remove it from the heat. 

 

info:
If the item details above aren't accurate or complete, we want to know about it. 

Specifications

  • Extra sharp yellow cheddar
  • 2 lbs.
  • Lactose-free
  • Gluten-free

Pumpkin Mac-n-Cheese Recipe

Grilled Cheese Portabello Caps Recipe

Member ratings & reviews

Filtered and sorted results would be available on the new 'Customer ratings & reviews' page.
Sort by |

Showing 1-3 of 235 reviews

Oct 30, 2025
Theresa
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Husband loves this cheese!

I bought this cheese because my club did not have any Member's Mark Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese. My husband likes the Member's Mark brand. After he tried this brand, he asked me where I got this cheese and to please keep buying this brand as it is the best that he has tried.

Helpful?1ZUDE7YHCJFU13857623529
Jun 22, 2026
Stoney
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Extra Sharp Cheddar

Nice cheese for a reasonable price.

Helpful?1ZUDE7YHCJFU13857623529
Feb 27, 2026
Arkie72401
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

great product

wonderful flavor and just the right size, i am tired of buying little bags that cost more and go bad much faster

Helpful?1ZUDE7YHCJFU13857623529