Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs.
Curbside Pickup

Highlights
- Super for snacking!
- Try it paired with roasted nuts and ice-cold ale
- Excellent for cooking
- Naturally lactose-free and gluten-free
Old Wisconsin Natural Cut Turkey Smoked Sausage & Colby Jack Cheese Bites, 1.5 oz., 6 ct.


Members also considered
Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs. $8.97 $4.49/lb
SponsoredCabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs.$8.97current price $8.97$4.49/lb18384.7737 out of 5 Stars. 1838 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Mexican Style Finely Shredded Cheese 2 pk. $6.44 $0.20/oz
Member's Mark Mexican Style Finely Shredded Cheese 2 pk.$6.44current price $6.44$0.20/oz77164.8039 out of 5 Stars. 7716 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryBelGioioso Pre-Sliced Fresh Mozzarella 32 oz. $6.28 Was $8.28 $0.20/oz
Instant Savings
Now $6.28current price Now $6.28, Was $8.28$8.28$0.20/ozBelGioioso Pre-Sliced Fresh Mozzarella 32 oz.$2 offEnds Aug 1632384.7628 out of 5 Stars. 3238 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryKerrygold Dubliner Cheese, 1.75 lbs. $12.87 $7.35/lb
SponsoredKerrygold Dubliner Cheese, 1.75 lbs.$12.87current price $12.87$7.35/lb13344.7556 out of 5 Stars. 1334 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Baby Swiss Cheese Slices 2 lbs. $7.82 $3.91/lb
Member's Mark Baby Swiss Cheese Slices 2 lbs.$7.82current price $7.82$3.91/lb44044.7545 out of 5 Stars. 4404 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryKraft Singles American Cheese Slices 3 lbs., 72 ct. $9.36 $0.13/ea
Kraft Singles American Cheese Slices 3 lbs., 72 ct.$9.36current price $9.36$0.13/ea135574.8198 out of 5 Stars. 13557 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Cracker Cut Gourmet Selection Imported Cheese Tray, 32 oz. $13.88 $0.43/oz
Member's Mark Cracker Cut Gourmet Selection Imported Cheese Tray, 32 oz.$13.88current price $13.88$0.43/oz24974.6235 out of 5 Stars. 2497 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark American Cheese 5 lbs., 160 slices $12.17 $2.43/lb
Member's Mark American Cheese 5 lbs., 160 slices$12.17current price $12.17$2.43/lb36124.6744 out of 5 Stars. 3612 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Smoked Provolone Cheese Slices, 2 lb. $7.36 $3.68/lb
Member's Mark Smoked Provolone Cheese Slices, 2 lb.$7.36current price $7.36$3.68/lb33084.6826 out of 5 Stars. 3308 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryFrigo Cheese Heads String Cheese 1 oz. pkg., 48 ct. $9.47 $0.20/ea
Frigo Cheese Heads String Cheese 1 oz. pkg., 48 ct.$9.47current price $9.47$0.20/ea78904.8428 out of 5 Stars. 7890 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryBelGioioso Shaved Cheese Blend 1.75 lbs. $9.86 $5.63/lb
BelGioioso Shaved Cheese Blend 1.75 lbs.$9.86current price $9.86$5.63/lb31434.798 out of 5 Stars. 3143 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryThe Laughing Cow Creamy Swiss Cheese Wedge, Original, 3 pk. $7.58 $2.53/ea
The Laughing Cow Creamy Swiss Cheese Wedge, Original, 3 pk.$7.58current price $7.58$2.53/ea15414.8164 out of 5 Stars. 1541 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMini Babybel Original Semisoft Cheese, 26 ct. $10.72 $0.41/ea
Mini Babybel Original Semisoft Cheese, 26 ct.$10.72current price $10.72$0.41/ea57964.815 out of 5 Stars. 5796 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDelivery
About this item
Product details
Creamy white in color and almost crumbly in texture, this Extra Sharp Cheddar packs a punch, followed by a citrusy tang. Magnificent melted into cheese sauce, or atop a juicy burger.
The Cabot Name Says It All
New England Cooperative Cabot Creamery, founded in 1919, is a nationally known name for award-winning cheese. 500 families own the creamery and supply the milk from their farms. Cabot NY Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Brick has an "East Coast cheddar bite", and with 7 grams of protein in every one-inch cube, it makes for excellent low-carbohydrate snacking. Pair it with fruit and a glass of wine or roasted nuts and chilled beer.
Ways to Use It
Grate this New York extra sharp yellow cheese over pasta to add pep, melt it on rustic bread for a sophisticated grilled cheese, sprinkle over grilled vegetables for a healthy entree, blend it into a simple quiche for that wow factor–or cut into cubes and eat it plain. Any way you slice it, it's good!
Easy to Melt
New York Extra Sharp is the perfect texture for melting. The preferred method for melting is to shred the cheese so that is uniformly shaped, then allow it to rise to room temperature. Make a roux of flour and fat (to thicken the sauce) in a non-stick skillet and then, keeping the heat on low, add the cheese. Stir frequently and don't walk away. Once the cheese is smooth, remove it from the heat.
Specifications
- Extra sharp yellow cheddar
- 2 lbs.
- Lactose-free
- Gluten-free
Member ratings & reviews
Filtered and sorted results would be available on the new 'Customer ratings & reviews' page.
Showing 1-3 of 233 reviews
Verified Purchase
Husband loves this cheese!
I bought this cheese because my club did not have any Member's Mark Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese. My husband likes the Member's Mark brand. After he tried this brand, he asked me where I got this cheese and to please keep buying this brand as it is the best that he has tried.
Verified Purchase
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Nice cheese for a reasonable price.
Verified Purchase
The best cheese!
I get this cheese to make pimento cheese and use in all my other recipes that call for cheddar. It has a great taste and melts smoothly in soups.
Items you may like
Old Wisconsin Natural Cut Turkey Smoked Sausage & Colby Jack Cheese Bites, 1.5 oz., 6 ct. $7.67 Was $8.67 $1.28/ea
Instant Savings
SponsoredNow $7.67current price Now $7.67, Was $8.67$8.67$1.28/eaOld Wisconsin Natural Cut Turkey Smoked Sausage & Colby Jack Cheese Bites, 1.5 oz., 6 ct.$1 offEnds Aug 16424.2857 out of 5 Stars. 42 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Part-Skim Shredded Mozzarella Cheese 5 lbs. $12.17 $2.43/lb
Member's Mark Part-Skim Shredded Mozzarella Cheese 5 lbs.$12.17current price $12.17$2.43/lb43314.7153 out of 5 Stars. 4331 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Colby and Monterey Jack Cheese Sticks, 36 ct. $7.87 $0.22/ea
Member's Mark Colby and Monterey Jack Cheese Sticks, 36 ct.$7.87current price $7.87$0.22/ea38354.769 out of 5 Stars. 3835 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliverySargento Fun! Balanced Breaks Variety Snack Kit, 2 oz., 8 ct. $11.47 $1.43/ea
SponsoredSargento Fun! Balanced Breaks Variety Snack Kit, 2 oz., 8 ct.$11.47current price $11.47$1.43/ea1144.4035 out of 5 Stars. 114 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Part-Skim Shredded Mozzarella Cheese 1 lb., 2 pk. $5.92 $0.18/oz
Member's Mark Part-Skim Shredded Mozzarella Cheese 1 lb., 2 pk.$5.92current price $5.92$0.18/oz30454.778 out of 5 Stars. 3045 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Shredded Parmesan Cheese, 24 oz. $10.74 $0.45/oz
Member's Mark Shredded Parmesan Cheese, 24 oz.$10.74current price $10.74$0.45/oz43794.6463 out of 5 Stars. 4379 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryBananas, 3 lbs. $1.47 $0.49/lb
Bananas, 3 lbs.$1.47current price $1.47$0.49/lb514104.6064 out of 5 Stars. 51410 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryRusset Potatoes, 10 lbs. $4.94 $0.49/lb
Russet Potatoes, 10 lbs.$4.94current price $4.94$0.49/lb116624.5659 out of 5 Stars. 11662 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryWhole Seedless Watermelon $6.97 $6.97/ea
Whole Seedless Watermelon$6.97current price $6.97$6.97/ea226113.7915 out of 5 Stars. 22611 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryGreen Seedless Grapes, 3 lbs. $6.87 $2.29/lb
Green Seedless Grapes, 3 lbs.$6.87current price $6.87$2.29/lb305664.4673 out of 5 Stars. 30566 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryDaisy Brand Pure and Natural Sour Cream, 48 oz. $5.54 $1.85/lb
Daisy Brand Pure and Natural Sour Cream, 48 oz.$5.54current price $5.54$1.85/lb71904.8636 out of 5 Stars. 7190 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Parmesan Cheese Wedge, priced per pound $16.45 $6.58/lb
Member's Mark Parmesan Cheese Wedge, priced per pound$16.45current price $16.45avg. price$6.58/lbFinal cost by weight14384.6544 out of 5 Stars. 1438 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryMember's Mark Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks, 36 ct. $8.56 $0.24/ea
Member's Mark Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks, 36 ct.$8.56current price $8.56$0.24/ea19024.6157 out of 5 Stars. 1902 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryEl Viajero Queso Fresco 2.2 lbs. $7.86 $3.57/lb
El Viajero Queso Fresco 2.2 lbs.$7.86current price $7.86$3.57/lb7634.6514 out of 5 Stars. 763 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryGO2snax, Hard Salami, Mild Cheddar Cheese, Chocolatey Caramels & Almonds, 2.15 oz. Each, 6 pk. $9.97 $1.66/ea
GO2snax, Hard Salami, Mild Cheddar Cheese, Chocolatey Caramels & Almonds, 2.15 oz. Each, 6 pk.$9.97current price $9.97$1.66/ea974.8247 out of 5 Stars. 97 reviewsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDelivery