Sam’s Club Bakery in Fishkill, NY #6356

56 W Merritt Blvd, Fishkill, NY 12524
Opens Tuesday 9am
(845) 896-4980Get Directions
Find another club

Club info

Club hours

Mon - Sun 9am - 8pm

Plus membership early hours

Mon - Sun 8am - 9am
Holiday hours may vary
Cake from Sam's Club

Member benefits

See all benefits
Curbside Pickup

Curbside Pickup

Free for all members with no order minimum or fees*.

Same-Day Delivery

Same-Day Delivery

Order by 1pm local time for same-day service.

Scan & Go Checkout

Scan & Go Checkout

Scan items as you shop, pay, and head to the door.

Member's Mark

Member's Mark

Created just for you at exclusive prices.

Sam’s Club Bakery in Wallkill #6423300 N Galleria DrMiddletown, NY 10941
Opens Tuesday 9am
845-692-510025 mi
Sam’s Club Bakery in Kingston #6201801 Frank Sottile BlvdKingston, NY 12401
Opens Tuesday 9am
845-382-132030 mi
Sam’s Club Bakery in Elmsford #6674333 Saw Mill River RdElmsford, NY 10523
Opens Tuesday 9am
914-592-002333 mi

About Sam's Club Bakery in Fishkill, NY

The Fishkill Sam's Club Bakery is committed to freshness and taste. Members can enjoy delicious treats made with premium ingredients at competitive prices, perfect for everyday indulgence or special occasions. Conveniently located at 56 W Merritt Blvd Fishkill, NY, 12524, the Sam's Club Bakery offers a wide variety of breads, pastries, cakes, and desserts. Custom cakes and bulk bakery items and supplies are also available to to suit personal and event needs.

How to Order Custom Cakes in Fishkill from Sam's Club

Ordering custom cakes from Sam’s Club is easy. Personalize your bakery item, pay, and pick up in club when it’s ready.

Here’s how it works:

  1. Browse our online selection of customizable cakes and cupcakes or select a design or theme from our online cake catalog.
  2. Start customizing your item by choosing which flavors and decorative options you want.
  3. Personalize your item by adding a custom message, if you choose.
  4. Review your item and schedule a pickup time at your Fishkill Sam's Club. Keep in mind that our Bakery needs at least a 24-hour notice. You'll receive an email when your cake is ready. At the club, pick it up in the bakery area.

If you need help with your cake order or have any questions, you can call your Fishkill Sam's Club at (845) 896-1746.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the soonest I can get a custom cake?

How far in advance can I order a custom cake?

Where do I pick up my custom cake order?

When will I know when my cake is ready?

What type of cakes are available to customize?