$250 - $499

Prices may vary in club and online
Sort by|

Cushion-Cut Blue Topaz Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold $949.00

Cushion-Cut Blue Topaz Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $949.00

Cushion-Cut Blue Topaz Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold

4.6 out of 5 Stars. 10 reviews
Available for Shipping

0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Band in 14K Gold $349.00

0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Band in 14K Gold
Rose, variant on 0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Band in 14K Gold
White, variant on 0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Band in 14K Gold
Yellow, variant on 0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Band in 14K Gold
current price $349.00

0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Band in 14K Gold

5 out of 5 Stars. 7 reviews
Available for Shipping

Panther Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold $1,195.00

Panther Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold
Yellow Gold, variant on Panther Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold
Two Tone Gold, variant on Panther Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold
current price $1,195.00
Options from $815.00 – $1,195.00

Panther Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 12 reviews
Available for Shipping

Cushion Checkerboard-Cut Madeira Citrine Leverback Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold $849.00

Cushion Checkerboard-Cut Madeira Citrine Leverback Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold
current price $849.00

Cushion Checkerboard-Cut Madeira Citrine Leverback Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

Available for Shipping

Morganite and Diamond Accent Double Halo Ring in 14K Gold $879.00

Morganite and Diamond Accent Double Halo Ring in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $879.00

Morganite and Diamond Accent Double Halo Ring in 14K Gold

4.1875 out of 5 Stars. 64 reviews
Available for Shipping

9-9.5 mm Round Cultured Freshwater Pearl and Blue Sapphire with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamond Earrings in 14K Gold $699.00

9-9.5 mm Round Cultured Freshwater Pearl and Blue Sapphire with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamond Earrings in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $699.00

9-9.5 mm Round Cultured Freshwater Pearl and Blue Sapphire with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamond Earrings in 14K Gold

3.75 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
Available for Shipping

Baguette-Cut Smokey Quartz and 0.22 CT. T.W. Diamond Halo Ring in 14K Gold $769.00

Baguette-Cut Smokey Quartz and 0.22 CT. T.W. Diamond Halo Ring in 14K Gold
current price $769.00

Baguette-Cut Smokey Quartz and 0.22 CT. T.W. Diamond Halo Ring in 14K Gold

4.5714 out of 5 Stars. 7 reviews
Available for Shipping

Disney Diamond Earrings in 14K White Gold $389.00

Disney Diamond Earrings in 14K White Gold
current price $389.00

Disney Diamond Earrings in 14K White Gold

4.25 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
Available for Shipping

Comfort Fit Wedding Band in 14K Gold, 3mm $399.00

Comfort Fit Wedding Band in 14K Gold, 3mm
Rose Gold, variant on Comfort Fit Wedding Band in 14K Gold, 3mm
Yellow Gold, variant on Comfort Fit Wedding Band in 14K Gold, 3mm
White Gold, variant on Comfort Fit Wedding Band in 14K Gold, 3mm
current price $399.00

Comfort Fit Wedding Band in 14K Gold, 3mm

4.4 out of 5 Stars. 30 reviews
Available for Shipping

Morganite and Diamond Accent Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold $749.00

Morganite and Diamond Accent Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $749.00

Morganite and Diamond Accent Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold

4.0952 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
Available for Shipping

Pear Cut Gemstone & Halo Diamond Tear Drop Dangle Earrings in 14K Gold $659.00

Pear Cut Gemstone & Halo Diamond Tear Drop Dangle Earrings in 14K Gold
Treated Morganite, variant on Pear Cut Gemstone & Halo Diamond Tear Drop Dangle Earrings in 14K Gold
Lab Created Blue Sapphire, variant on Pear Cut Gemstone & Halo Diamond Tear Drop Dangle Earrings in 14K Gold
Lab Created Emerald, variant on Pear Cut Gemstone & Halo Diamond Tear Drop Dangle Earrings in 14K Gold
Lab Created White Sapphire, variant on Pear Cut Gemstone & Halo Diamond Tear Drop Dangle Earrings in 14K Gold
current price $659.00
Options from $659.00 – $729.00

Pear Cut Gemstone & Halo Diamond Tear Drop Dangle Earrings in 14K Gold

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Available for Shipping

Mommy and Me Curb ID Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold $299.00

Mommy and Me Curb ID Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold
current price $299.00

Mommy and Me Curb ID Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold

4.2609 out of 5 Stars. 23 reviews
Out of stock

Frequently Asked Questions

Is 14K gold better for gifts than 10K gold?

Can I find certified diamonds in this price range?

What is the benefit of a "hinged" bangle?

How should I care about gemstone jewelry?

Is lab-grown diamond jewelry a good investment for a gift?

About Jewelry under $500 - Shop Jewelry by Price

Elevate Your Gifting Experience

Celebrate milestones and create lasting memories with the Gifting Jewelry $250 - $499 collection at Sam’s Club. This carefully curated range offers the perfect balance of prestige and value, featuring solid 14K Gold Designs and higher-carat Diamond jewelry. Whether you are marking an anniversary, a promotion, or a significant birthday, these pieces offer the weight and brilliance of professional-grade fine jewelry.

From Gold Staples to Diamond Essentials

Our mid-range luxury collection is designed to provide high-impact style for every personality. Explore our specialized categories to find a gift that speaks volumes:

Timeless Gold Staples:

Brilliant Diamond Essentials:

  • Sparkling Studs & Hoops: Shop our Diamond Earrings and shimmering hoops. These pieces utilize higher-quality stones to ensure maximum fire and brilliance.

Precious Gemstone Rings:

Modern Lab-Grown Diamonds:

  • Advanced Brilliance: Explore Lab-Grown Diamond Pendants that provide a larger look and exceptional clarity, allowing you to maximize your $500 budget.

Gift Selection: Fine Jewelry $250 - $499

Model Category Best For Top Recommendation
14K Gold Chains Signature daily style; substantial gold weight and unique design for everyday wear. Three Bead Necklace Earring Set
Diamond Studs Anniversaries and birthdays; essential diamond solitaires that offer timeless sparkle and prestige. 1/2 CT TW Diamond Studs
Gemstone Luxury Milestone celebrations; high-end precious stones like sapphires set in intricate gold settings. Sapphire & Diamond Halo
Gold Bangles Sophisticated wristwear; high-polish 14K gold bangles that provide a structured, polished look. 14K High-Polished Bangle

Why Buy Mid-Range Jewelry from Sam’s Club?

  • Wholesale Value: Our jewelry collection offers quality at prices that reflect our warehouse mission.
  • Ethically Sourced: All diamonds are conflict-free and adhere to the Kimberley Process, ensuring your gift represents beauty and responsibility.
  • Independent Grading: Most diamond items in the $400+ range include reports from IGI or GIA, providing professional verification of your stone's quality.
  • Plus Member Exclusive: Get access to a variety of fine jewelry collection and exclusive members’ only pricing.