Customer reviews for Member's Mark 450-Thread-Count Solid Sheet Set, Assorted Sizes forMember's Mark 450-Thread-Count Solid Sheet Set, Assorted Sizes
Most helpful positive review
8 customers found this helpful
5 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Best sheets ever!
unhappykelly
Most helpful negative review
10 customers found this helpful
1 out of 5 stars review
Will never buy again!
Lori
8,502 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 1 out of 5 stars review2/2/2026These sheets are terrible. I bought these in December 2024. I don't know how many flat sheets I've gone through. Every bed I've put them on end up with them disintegrating, leaving a hole in areas of the sheet barely touched. Am I expecting too much for a sheet to last a year?
Will never buy again!
Lori - 2 out of 5 stars review5/3/2026I used to love these sheets, but now the quality is just going down. The older sets I have are still great but the last two sets I purchased have gotten rips in the seams. This newest set had them after the first wash. Didn’t even make it on the bed. Sad the quality isn’t there, especially when they’re almost $80. Review won’t let me upload photo proof either :/
Poor Quality
KateF - 2 out of 5 stars review6/14/2026the elastic lost its stretch only a couple years possibly a few years. I loved this set because it actually fit my king size bed as well as it had tabs around the inside to indicate if it was for a side or the for the top or bottom. I don't recall which set it was but it's 100% cotton by Members Mark.
Elastic wore out fast
Kathryn - 1 out of 5 stars review2/5/2026After I bought these I put them in the wash machine before I put on my bed. The seam on the flat sheet came completely apart and there was a hole in one of the pillow cases
Fell apart
Rachael - 3 out of 5 stars review4/5/2026Excellent sheets. Breathable and luxurious feeling. However, purchased March 2026 for $49.99, regular price. Went to purchase today, April 2026, and price is $68.48!!! Ridiculous. That’s a 37% price increase.
37% Price Hike
MARIA909 - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/16/2016Maybe a bad batch? These were supposed to be white. When taking them out pf package to be washed I noticed they didnt appear to be as white as previous sets we have purchsed. They also were not as soft or thick. I put them up next to another set and they looked a very light cream, checked the package and it said white. I love how these wash and feel but this set didnt have the feel of others. I would still recommend, the price is great!
Not like ones I have purchased in store
Linda - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/29/2023Fitted sheet had large orange writing on it and was two pieces of cloth stitched together. Not quality sheets. Returned with no replacement purchase. Factory where produced must need better quality control. I had one of these sheet sets before and it was great.
Seconda
Trouble JoWelspun TeamHi Jo, thank you for bringing this to our attention and we deeply apologize that this product did not meet your expectations... - 2 out of 5 stars review11/22/2025I've bought these sheets for YEARS but the set I just bought fits so weird. The corners don't line up and when I put the last corner on another one wants to pop off. So disappointed in these sheets. I literally only have a club card so I could buy these. I probably won't renew.HEATHER
- 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase2/8/2022What happened! I purchased these same sheets last year and absolute love them. The same sheets this time around puckered and lost their smooth texture after washing them per the instructions. They never made it to the bed. I returned them. Assuming Makers Mark changed suppliers or something.
Something went wrong!
Patty - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase7/8/2021I bought these sheets from Sam’s Club 5 years ago and loved them. They were more wrinkle free than these sheets. They also felt crisp when going to bed even after the first use after washing them. The sheets I recently purchased do not, and they wrinkle like any other sheet. I believe the difference is in the thread count. I don’t recall the older sheets having 450 threads per inch. Would much prefer the same sheets I bought 5 years ago for $10 less.
Not improved, bring back the old.
DWI - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/19/2024Not the same! 😔 While still comfortable they are not the same. I purchased 2 of the same items and they are not exact. One set set wrinkled badly and has pull stripe marks on the top sheet. Two of the four pilliw cases barely fit my pillows. Wish Sams would quit messing with what were once good products.
Not the same! 😔
ReginaWelspun TeamHello Regina,Thank you for reaching out and sharing your concern with us. I’m truly sorry to hear that the product didn’t me... - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/19/2016I became a big fan of these sheets when they were sold at Sam's a few years ago under the Christy brand name. I recently upgraded to a king and was desperately searching for the Christy sheets, which I could no longer find. After researching a bunch of sites, and finding the original web ad for the Christy sheets, I noticed these new sheets with the same exact description, being sold now under Sam's brand! I quickly ordered a king set in white. they are the same sheets!!! I'm so so happy. Ok now about the sheets...they are soft and solid heavy weight cotton 100%. They feel very expensive and they are so durable. I've had two queen sets for a few years and have fun them through hundreds of wash cycles, and they are still like brand new. No p...
Best sheets ever!
unhappykelly - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/1/2022These used to be my favorite sheets, but I believe they changed the fabric. They used to be soft but crisp, regardless of how many times they were washed. Now they have lost the crispness I like, and are just overly soft and seem hot to me. Why did they mess with perfection??
Too soft
Rloethen - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase8/27/2018I have been buying these sheets since 2011 to use in my bed & breakfast. As much as I like the sheets, I have noticed changes through the years - some good, some bad. The good: deep pockets with better elastic on the fitted sheets, and the sides, top & bottom are labeled so you know which direction to put it on the mattress. The bad: the cotton fabric seems rougher than in previous years. The sheets used to be super-soft & smooth right from the package. My guests commented on how soft they were. The more recent ones I purchased are not soft or smooth, and the sheets do not wear as well. My newer (~2-years-old) fitted sheets have developed holes, and my older fitted sheets are still intact. Stitching on the sides of the newer flat sheets...
What happened to quality control?
erdainnkeeper - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase1/29/2022These sheets are the perfect weight and have a very nice feel to them. The wash great and they fit the bottom sheet fits the bed perfectly. They are marked top/bottom or side to make it even easier to get the sheet on the bed quickly. I have 3 sets of these and will be purchasing more for my daughter.
Love these Sheets!
WK - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/9/2019Bought this during the Big Sale, and was excited to give these sheets to my sons. They appeared to be the same brand as the set my mom had bought for me a short time ago. However I was disappointed, these sheets are not nearly as soft as mine, now they just lie in our linen closet.
Disappointed!
Daughter of King Jesus - 2 out of 5 stars review1/16/2026I’m not sure what’s going on here with the sheet sets. We’ve been buying them for years and the quality was great. However the last 3 sets I purchased all frayed after ONE wash. The quality definitely isn’t there anymore. Too bad as I won’t be purchasing them again.
So bummed
Michelle - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/7/2016I bought two sets of these about 3 weeks ago and I absolutely love them. They are very soft and very well made. Very deep pockets. I bought to fit over a 4" memory foam topper and they have room to spare and the corners hold better than any sheets I've ever had.
Great quality!
Riverkat - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase2/17/2023Purchased these sheets for my twin xl mattress. The fit was great even though I was initially thrown by the size stated as “twin/twin xl.” They feel wonderfully smooth and laundered quite well, coming out of the dryer soft and wrinkle free. A very good value for the price!
Excellent Sheets
Nancy - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase1/1/2024I’ve purchased these sheets for several years now and I’ve always been satisfied. This time not so much. I washed them and when I pulled them out of the washer the edges come apart and unraveled. The sheets are not the same as before and you can tell they are not as good as they use to be. The quality is just not the same, it’s like they are cheap dollar general sheets.
Not like they use to be, not good quality anymore
CBWelspun TeamHi CB, we deeply apologize that this product did not meet your expectations. Member's Mark items carry a 100% member satisfa...